Skip to main content

Research Repository

Advanced Search

The Intrinsic Value of Registered Partnerships and Marriage for Same-sex Couples, their Recognition Domestically and at the Strasbourg Court

Fenwick, Helen; Hayward, Andy

The Intrinsic Value of Registered Partnerships and Marriage for Same-sex Couples, their Recognition Domestically and at the Strasbourg Court Thumbnail


Authors



Contributors

Paul Behrens
Editor

Sean Becker
Editor

Abstract

Only a minority of jurisdictions currently permit same-sex marriage – among them, England and Wales (from 2013), Scotland (from 2014) and Northern Ireland (from 2020). This chapter explores the drive towards marriage equality from a domestic perspective and through the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR). On the latter point, the authors explore the ECtHR stance on civil partnerships and same-sex marriage under the European Convention on Human Rights and argue that the court's current approach shows tensions between two conflicting demands: the protection of sexual minorities, but also the safeguarding of its own authority through a doctrine of 'consensus', which avoids determinations that could lead to open conflict with several member states. Where the formalisation of same-sex relationships is concerned, 'East'/'West' divisions appear to exert inhibitory impact on the judgments, accommodated mainly via consensus analysis. This chapter considers ways of reconciling the two apparently conflicting aims. The authors conclude that reliance on consensus analysis means that the ECtHR is showing some willingness to open non-traditional institutions for formalising relationships in the form of registered partnerships to same-sex couples under the right to respect for private and family life. This approach, however, can be contrasted with the court’s reluctance to open the traditional institution of marriage to such couples under the right to marry.

Citation

Fenwick, H., & Hayward, A. (2023). The Intrinsic Value of Registered Partnerships and Marriage for Same-sex Couples, their Recognition Domestically and at the Strasbourg Court. In P. Behrens, & S. Becker (Eds.), Justice After Stonewall: LGBT Life between Challenge and Change. Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003286295-13

Online Publication Date Jan 31, 2023
Publication Date 2023-01
Deposit Date Sep 28, 2022
Publicly Available Date Aug 1, 2024
Publisher Routledge
Edition 1st ed.
Book Title Justice After Stonewall: LGBT Life between Challenge and Change
Chapter Number 10
DOI https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003286295-13
Public URL https://durham-repository.worktribe.com/output/1620935

Files

Accepted Book Chapter (304 Kb)
PDF

Copyright Statement
This is an Accepted Manuscript of a book chapter published by Routledge in Justice After Stonewall: LGBT Life between Challenge and Change on 31 January 2023, available online: http://www.routledge.com/9781032260525






You might also like



Downloadable Citations