On the accuracy of dark matter halo merger trees and the consequences for semi-analytic models of galaxy formation

Chandro-Gómez, Ángel; Lagos, Claudia del P.; Power, Chris; Moreno, Victor J. Forouhar; Helly, John C.; Lacey, Cedric G.; McGibbon, Robert J.; Schaller, Matthieu; Schaye, Joop

Abstract

Galaxy formation and evolution models, such as semi-analytic models, are powerful theoretical tools for predicting how galaxies evolve across cosmic time. These models follow the evolution of galaxies based on the halo assembly histories inferred from large N-body cosmological simulations. This process requires codes to identify haloes (‘halo finder’) and to track their time evolution (‘tree builder’). While these codes generally perform well, they encounter numerical issues when handling dense environments. In this paper, we present how relevant these issues are in state-of-the-art cosmological simulations. We characterize two major numerical artefacts in halo assembly histories: (i) the non-physical swapping of large amounts of mass between subhaloes, and (ii) the sudden formation of already massive subhaloes at late cosmic times. We quantify these artefacts for different combinations of halo finder (Subfind, VELOCIraptor, HBT-HERONS) and tree builder codes (D-Trees + DHalo, TreeFrog, HBT-HERONS), finding that in general more than 50 per cent (80 per cent) of the more massive subhaloes with >103 (> 104) particles at z = 0 inherit them in most cases. However, HBT-HERONS, which explicitly incorporates temporal information, effectively reduces the occurrence of these artefacts to 5 per cent (10 per cent). We then use the semi-analytic models Shark and Galform to explore how these artefacts impact galaxy formation predictions. We demonstrate that the issues above lead to non-physical predictions in galaxies hosted by affected haloes, particularly in Shark where the modelling of baryons relies on subhalo information. Finally, we propose and implement fixes for the numerical artefacts at the semi-analytic model level, and use Shark to show the improvements, especially at the high-mass end, after applying them.

Citation

Chandro-Gómez, Á., Lagos, C. D. P., Power, C., Moreno, V. J. F., Helly, J. C., Lacey, C. G., McGibbon, R. J., Schaller, M., & Schaye, J. (2025). On the accuracy of dark matter halo merger trees and the consequences for semi-analytic models of galaxy formation. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 539(2), 776-807. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/staf519

• Journal Article Type: Article
• Acceptance Date: Mar 26, 2025
• Online Publication Date: Mar 31, 2025
• Publication Date: Apr 15, 2025
• Deposit Date: May 28, 2025
• Publicly Available Date: May 28, 2025
• Journal: Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
• Print ISSN: 0035-8711
• Electronic ISSN: 1365-2966
• Publisher: Royal Astronomical Society
• Peer Reviewed: Peer Reviewed
• Volume: 539
• Issue: 2
• Pages: 776-807
• DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/staf519
• Public URL: https://durham-repository.worktribe.com/output/3965918