Skip to main content

Research Repository

Advanced Search

How Should Evidence Inform Education Policy?

Joyce, Kathryn E.; Cartwright, Nancy


Kathryn E. Joyce


Randall Curren


This chapter explores how evidence from various sources can support education policy decisions. Although policy arguments include some normative premises, we focus on the evidence needed to support their descriptive premises, homing in on predictions about how candidate policies are likely to perform in specific target sites. Although evidence from RCTs is viewed as the gold-standard, the chapter argues that it is insufficient and unnecessary for predictions about education policies. Trustworthy predictions require information about how the policy operates, the conditions under which it can do so, and the conditions present in the target setting, which comes from a mix of research methods, theory, and local sources. This evidence is also useful for feasibility assessments and implementation planning.


Joyce, K. E., & Cartwright, N. (2022). How Should Evidence Inform Education Policy?. In R. Curren (Ed.), Handbook of Philosophy of Education. Taylor and Francis.

Online Publication Date Oct 26, 2022
Publication Date Oct 26, 2022
Deposit Date Jun 21, 2024
Publisher Taylor and Francis
Edition 1st ed.
Book Title Handbook of Philosophy of Education
Public URL