Skip to main content

Research Repository

Advanced Search

ELT-scale elongated LGS wavefront sensing: on-sky results

Bardou, Lisa; Gendron, Eric; Rousset, Gerard; Gratadour, Damien; Basden, Alastair; Bonaccini Calia, Domenico; Buey, Tristan; Centrone, Mauro; Chemla, Fanny; Gach, Jean-Luc; Geng, Deli; Hubert, Zoltan; Laidlaw, Douglas J.; Morris, Timothy J.; Myers, Richard M.; Osborn, James; Reeves, Andrew P.; Townson, Matthew J.; Vidal, Fabrice

ELT-scale elongated LGS wavefront sensing: on-sky results Thumbnail


Eric Gendron

Gerard Rousset

Damien Gratadour

Alastair Basden

Domenico Bonaccini Calia

Tristan Buey

Mauro Centrone

Fanny Chemla

Jean-Luc Gach

Deli Geng

Zoltan Hubert

Douglas J. Laidlaw

Timothy J. Morris

Richard M. Myers

Andrew P. Reeves

Fabrice Vidal


Context. Laser guide stars (LGS) allow adaptive optics (AO) systems to reach greater sky coverage, especially for AO systems correcting the atmospheric turbulence on large fields of view. However LGS suffer from limitations, among which is their apparent elongation which can reach 20 arcsec when observed with large aperture telescopes such as the European Southern Observatory 39 m telescope. The consequences of this extreme elongation have been studied in simulations and laboratory experiments, although never on-sky, yet understanding and mitigating those effects is key to taking full advantage of the Extremely Large Telescope (ELT) six LGS. Aims. In this paper we study the impact of wavefront sensing with an ELT-scale elongated LGS using on-sky data obtained with the AO demonstrator CANARY on the William Herschel telescope (WHT) and the ESO Wendelstein LGS unit. CANARY simultaneously observed a natural guide star and a superimposed LGS launched from a telescope placed 40 m away from the WHT pupil. Methods. Comparison of the wavefronts measured with each guide star allows the determination of an error breakdown of the elongated LGS wavefront sensing. With this error breakdown, we isolate the contribution of the LGS elongation and study its impact. We also investigate the effects of truncation or undersampling of the LGS spots. Results. We successfully used the elongated LGS wavefront sensor (WFS) to drive the AO loop during on-sky operations, but it necessitated regular calibrations of the non-common path aberrations on the LGS WFS arm. In the off-line processing of the data collected on-sky we separate the error term encapsulating the impact of LGS elongation in a dynamic and quasi-static component. We measure errors varying from 0 nm to 160 nm rms for the dynamic error and we are able to link it to turbulence strength and spot elongation. The quasi-static errors are significant and vary between 20 nm and 200 nm rms depending on the conditions. They also increase by as much as 70 nm over the course of 10 m. We do not observe any impact when undersampling the spots with pixel scales as large as 1.95″, while the LGS spot full width half maximum varies from 1.7″ to 2.2″; however, significant errors appear when truncating the spots. These errors appear for fields of view smaller than 10.4″ to 15.6″, depending on the spots’ elongations. Translated to the ELT observing at zenith, elongations as long as 23.5″ must be accommodated, corresponding to a field of view of 16.3″ if the most elongated spots are put across the diagonal of the subaperture.


Bardou, L., Gendron, E., Rousset, G., Gratadour, D., Basden, A., Bonaccini Calia, D., …Vidal, F. (2021). ELT-scale elongated LGS wavefront sensing: on-sky results. Astronomy & Astrophysics, 649, Article A158.

Journal Article Type Article
Acceptance Date Sep 16, 2020
Online Publication Date Jun 1, 2021
Publication Date 2021-05
Deposit Date May 5, 2020
Publicly Available Date Jun 24, 2021
Journal Astronomy and Astrophysics
Print ISSN 0004-6361
Electronic ISSN 1432-0746
Publisher EDP Sciences
Peer Reviewed Peer Reviewed
Volume 649
Article Number A158
Public URL


You might also like

Downloadable Citations