Skip to main content

Research Repository

Advanced Search

‘Finding ‘East’/’West’ divisions in Council of Europe states on treatment of sexual minorities: the response of the Strasbourg Court and the role of consensus analysis’

Fenwick, H; Fenwick, D

‘Finding ‘East’/’West’ divisions in Council of Europe states on treatment of sexual minorities: the response of the Strasbourg Court and the role of consensus analysis’ Thumbnail


Authors



Abstract

Manifestations of prejudice against sexual minorities are currently especially resurgent in certain “Eastern” Council of Europe Member States. This article argues that the current approach at the Strasbourg Court in this context shows tensions between two conflicting demands: it is seeking both to protect sexual minorities, but also its own authority, by relying on the consensus doctrine to avoid determinations likely to lead to open conflict with such states. In respect of homophobic hate crimes and bans on public manifestations of support for sexual minorities, the Court has shown a robust determination to provide protection for such minorities, partly on the basis that there is no consensus among the Member State supporting such practices. But, in strong contrast, in the context of formalisations of same-sex relationships, there are signs that “East”/“West” divisions are having some inhibitory impact on its judgments, accommodated mainly via consensus analysis. This article therefore considers ways of reconciling the two apparently conflicting aims of the Court identified.

Citation

Fenwick, H., & Fenwick, D. (2019). ‘Finding ‘East’/’West’ divisions in Council of Europe states on treatment of sexual minorities: the response of the Strasbourg Court and the role of consensus analysis’. European Human Rights Law Review, 3, 247-273

Journal Article Type Article
Acceptance Date Apr 22, 2019
Publication Date Jan 1, 2019
Deposit Date Jul 18, 2019
Publicly Available Date Jul 1, 2020
Journal European Human Rights Law Review
Print ISSN 1361-1526
Publisher Sweet and Maxwell
Peer Reviewed Peer Reviewed
Volume 3
Pages 247-273
Publisher URL https://www.sweetandmaxwell.co.uk/Catalogue/ProductDetails.aspx?productid=30791306&recordid=388

Files

Accepted Journal Article (499 Kb)
PDF

Copyright Statement
This is a pre-copyedited, author-produced version of an article accepted for publication in European Human Rights Law Review following peer review. The definitive published version Fenwick, H. & Fenwick, D. (2019). ‘Finding ‘East’/’West’ divisions in Council of Europe states on treatment of sexual minorities: the response of the Strasbourg Court and the role of consensus analysis’. European Human Rights Law Review 3: 247-273 is available online on Westlaw UK or from Thomson Reuters DocDel service.







You might also like



Downloadable Citations